top of page

Four Units on a Difficult Sloping Site: A Hard-Fought Planning Permit issued yesterday

Writer: Swarup Dutta
Swarup Dutta
4 days ago
3 min read

Updated: 2 days ago





Some projects test every part of the design and planning process. This four-unit development was one of them.


The site was just 1,058 square metres, steeply sloping, and constrained by trees, access, neighbourhood expectations, and a Council that was not initially supportive. Many other practices had told the client that three units was the maximum achievable outcome. We believed a carefully resolved four-unit design could work—and ultimately secured a permit for four dwellings: three 4-bedroom homes and one 3-bedroom home.


A Difficult Starting Point

Council raised barriers from the outset. The client’s neighbour had warned him that a previous four-unit proposal on the street had been refused, and that a maximum of three dwellings was considered more acceptable.


There was also an existing arborist report supporting tree removal, prepared before I took on the project. That meant we had to respond carefully to Council’s questions about vegetation, canopy coverage, and the impact of the proposal on the surrounding landscape.


The brief was ambitious, but the constraints were real. The design needed to demonstrate that four homes could sit comfortably on the site without overwhelming the neighbourhood or compromising amenity.


Designing Four Homes, Not One Building

One of the biggest design challenges was avoiding the appearance of a single, continuous four-unit building. Four attached dwellings with no visible separation could easily have read as an overly dense, monolithic form.


Our response was to treat the development as four individual homes, each with its own roof form and architectural identity. This broke down the building mass, created variation across the site, and helped the proposal read more like a group of dwellings than a large apartment-style development.


The roof forms became a key part of the design language. Rather than one long, unbroken roofline, the homes were articulated to give each dwelling its own presence and address.






Steep Site, Tight Access

The sloping site created further complications. Designing driveways, levels, retaining, transitions between spaces, and safe vehicle access required careful coordination.


We were working with the worst-case scenario: a narrow driveway. Council’s traffic engineer resisted the designs and swept-path diagrams provided by our traffic engineer, creating another layer of scrutiny around vehicle movement and access.


Every millimetre mattered. The access design had to work practically for residents while also satisfying Council’s technical requirements.


Trees and Canopies Overlapping Roofs

Vegetation was another major issue. The site’s existing trees, canopy coverage, and potential conflicts between tree canopies and building roofs required careful resolution.


We had to balance the client’s desire to remove certain trees with Council’s expectations around landscaping, canopy retention, and neighbourhood character. The design needed to demonstrate that the proposal could accommodate appropriate landscaping while still delivering four viable homes.


The Outcome

Despite the obstacles, the project achieved a planning permit this week for:


Four dwellings on a 1,058 square metre sloping site


Three 4-bedroom homes


One 3-bedroom home


A design that articulated the development as four individual dwellings rather than one continuous building


A resolved response to steep-site access, driveway design, traffic engineering concerns, and vegetation constraints


The client had been told by several other practices that three units was the maximum. This project shows that a well-reasoned design response, persistence, and a clear understanding of Council’s concerns can sometimes unlock a better outcome.


What This Project Shows

Every difficult site has a solution—but it is rarely obvious at the beginning. This project required us to challenge assumptions, test the design carefully, respond to technical objections, and find a form that worked with the slope, the trees, and the street context.


The result was not simply an extra dwelling. It was a better use of the site, delivered through a design that respected its constraints while creating four genuinely liveable homes.


Contact Swarup for your next poject

Comments


Swarup Dutta is the owner of this domain name and rebranded the website to give it a personal touch.

* Swarup, our Founder, while consulting to a Property Subdivision firm, developers and architects managed 250+ property subdivision permits.

Disclaimer & Terms of Engagement

The information provided on this website is general in nature.

Please note the following:

  • Preliminary Nature: All yield projections, building envelopes, and feasibility data are preliminary. They are subject to formal site surveys, soil reports, and final design drafting.

  • Statutory Authority: While we leverage deep expertise to mitigate risk, the final decision regarding any Planning Permit rests solely with the relevant Local Government Authority (Council) or VCAT.

  • 2026 Costings: Construction estimates and trade rates are based on current 2026 Victorian market benchmarks and are subject to fluctuation based on site-specific complexities and final builder tenders.

  • Professional Advice: This guidance does not constitute legal or financial advice. We recommend all clients consult with a qualified legal practitioner regarding Title Covenants and a financial advisor regarding project funding and tax implications.

AuArchitecture reserves the right to refine project strategies as detailed site data becomes available.

We advise you must seek legal and financial advice prior to making a commitment on any property development venture. The opinions we provide are general in nature.

© Copyright
bottom of page